The career mistake I made for way too long


At the start of my career, I was a hustler. (Of course... I still am, 25 years later)!

I was constantly going above and beyond, raising my hand, taking on more, contributing, adding value. And for a while, that seemed to work. I got promotions. I got pay increases. It felt like effort and results were lining up.

Until they weren’t.

At one point, my responsibilities kept growing, but the recognition stopped. No title change. No meaningful pay increase. Just... crickets.

Meanwhile, new people were coming into the company at significantly higher salaries than mine. It didn’t take long to realize I had made a major mistake: I assumed it would all work itself out. I thought surely they saw the value I was bringing. Surely it would get recognized. Surely the right thing would happen.

It didn’t.

There was even a stretch where my title didn’t come close to reflecting what I was actually doing.

Was it confidence? Fear of rocking the boat? Not wanting to seem difficult? Probably all of the above. But looking back, the bigger issue was that I didn’t have the tools. I didn’t know how to make the case clearly, professionally, and confidently. I didn’t know how to separate emotion from facts, or effort from business value.

Fast forward a few years, and I’ve now sat on the other side of the table too — as a manager and as a CEO. I’ve seen people advocate for themselves really well, and I’ve seen people completely miss the mark.

That’s why this conversation matters.

Negotiating for yourself can feel uncomfortable, loaded, and personal. But it does not have to be messy. With the right framework, the right preparation, and the right timing, you can advocate for yourself in a way that is grounded, credible, and much harder to dismiss.

In my latest episode of Loud & Lifted, I sit down with Bhavana Smith, founder of Until There Are Nine, to talk about how women can stop hoping they’ll be noticed and start making a strong case for what they’ve earned.

We get into:

  • why hard work alone is not enough
  • the mindset shifts that keep women from asking
  • how to make your case with facts, not feelings
  • what to do before you ask for more money, a promotion, or a title change
  • how to approach negotiation with more confidence and less fear

If you’ve ever thought, they should already know what I bring to the table, this episode is for you.

You have to know your value.
You have to communicate it clearly.
And yes... you have to ask.

Listen here:
Spotify
Apple
YouTube

I’d love to hear what hits home for you in this one!

Betsy

Introducing Loud & Lifted Circles! We are cranking up the volume! Loud & Lifted is launching in person peer groups in Harrisburg, PA.

Loud & Lifted

Real talk for women in leadership—delivered every other Thursday. Short, story-driven notes on confidence, visibility, hard conversations, and building a career you actually want. Expect practical tools, honest takes, and the occasional “wait… I needed that” moment.

Read more from Loud & Lifted

We’re turning up the volume! Loud & Lifted is now launching a monthly, in-person circle for real support, practical strategy, and forward momentum. Leading is heavy, and women are often carrying the job and the emotional labor without enough support. This is your monthly reset: perspective, strategy, and encouragement with women who get it. You’ll leave every meeting with one clear action, and a circle of peers who help you follow through. What You'll Get A small, trusted group of women...

Intuition, Precision, and Cutting Through the Noise Hey friends— Through the first year of Loud & Lifted, we’ve lived in the “professional development” lane. Which I love. Give me the frameworks, the tools, the assessments, the action plans. But if I’m being honest… I’ve always had one foot in the holistic, spiritual side too. I do yoga. I try to meditate (emphasis on try). I’ve burned sage more than once to clear out the bad vibes. And yes, I have absolutely wandered into a crystal shop...

glass wall

Issue #4 Welcome to 2026. We’re done pretending this is fixed. We’ve all heard of the glass ceiling — that invisible barrier that keeps women from getting promoted to the top. But what if the bigger issue isn’t above us…it’s all around us? Dr. Amy Diehl calls them glass walls. Picture it: unlike the “glass ceiling” that blocks upward movement, glass walls are those invisible barriers in every direction we turn — quietly blocking access to roles, relationships, and influence. And if you’re...